We're CYA Insurance Agency — Your Independent Insurance Agency
Genuinely invested in helping you find coverage that fits. No quotas, no pressure — just honest guidance from licensed agents serving Oklahoma, Texas, and Florida.
★★★★★ Independent Oklahoma brokerage · Multiple carriers compared · No cost to you
Our Story as an Independent Insurance Agency.
CYA Insurance Agency was founded in Oklahoma City on January 1st, 2017 by Trent Jones with one mission: give families access to the same quality insurance guidance that used to be reserved for people who knew the right people. Tracey Mosley joined in 2020, and together with Ericka McMahan, the team has grown into a full-service independent brokerage now licensed in Oklahoma, Texas, and Florida.
​
We're not tied to any single carrier — which means our recommendations are based on your needs, budget, doctors, prescriptions, and coverage goals, not a carrier quota. Nearly a decade later, we've helped hundreds of families across all three states find coverage they understand, at a price that makes sense.
Licensed in Oklahoma, Texas & Florida
BBB Accredited Business
Serving Families Since 2017
Why Choose an Independent Broker?
We Answer the Phone
When you have a billing question, a plan change, or just need to talk through your options, you get a real local person who knows your name. You'll also have our mobile number to text.
We Shop the Market For You
We're contracted with multiple top insurance companies, which means our recommendations are based on your doctors, your prescriptions, and your budget — not on any one carrier relationship.
We're Here After Enrollment
Our job doesn't end when you sign up. Annual reviews, coverage questions, life changes — we're your agent for the long haul. Whether you need to add a family member, switch plans at renewal, or just have a question, we're a call or text away.
Meet Our Team
Three licensed agents. One mission — finding the right coverage for you.
Tracey Mosley
Licensed Insurance Agent
Tracey spent eight years at Boeing before leaving to join CYA in 2020 — which means she's comfortable with complexity and knows how to explain it clearly. Clients consistently say she has a gift for making confusing insurance decisions feel simple and manageable. She joined CYA because she believed people deserved an agent who would actually listen before recommending a plan.
Phone: 405-613-1245
Email: tracey@cyamarket.com
Ericka McMahan
Licensed Insurance Agent
Ericka joined the CYA team bringing an unexpected background — a master's degree in geology from Florida State University. It turns out that analyzing complex data and explaining it clearly translates perfectly to insurance. She brings genuine care and patience to every consultation and is the kind of agent who remembers the details — because the details matter.
Phone: 405-628-7262
Email: ericka@cyamarket.com
Trent Jones
Founder and Sales Leader
Licensed Insurance Agent
Trent started CYA Insurance Agency in 2017 after seeing too many families feel rushed, confused, or pushed toward coverage that didn’t truly fit their needs. As founder and Sales Leader, he brings a decade of experience and a straightforward approach: find the right plan for the right person, every time.
Phone: 405-401-6373
Email: trent@cyamarket.com
What You Can Expect From Us
You can expect straight answers, plain-English explanations, and guidance based on your situation — not a carrier quota. We help you compare your options before you decide, and we stay available after enrollment when questions, renewals, or life changes come up.
One Agent, Every Year
You work with the same licensed agent who knows your history, your family, and your coverage — not a call center.
Why Clients Stay With CYA
Enrollment is just the beginning. Here's what our clients count on year after year.
Annual Coverage Reviews
Every year, we review your plan against what's new to make sure your coverage still fits your life and your budget.
Help After You Enroll
Claims questions, billing issues, new cards, life changes — call us first. That's what we're here for.