Medicare & Health Insurance Broker
Guthrie, Oklahoma
Independent. Local. On Your Side.
Local Expertise for Guthrie Residents
Guthrie is one of Oklahoma's most historically rich cities and the original state capital, with a growing retiree community that has made Logan County one of the faster-growing areas north of the OKC metro. Many Guthrie residents are turning 65 and entering Medicare for the first time, often without a local agent they trust to walk them through their options. CYA Market serves Guthrie and Logan County residents with the same free, no-pressure consultation process we use across the OKC metro — so you get big-city expertise with a small-town feel.
CYA Insurance Agency
✅ Local Agent Who Knows Oklahoma
✅ We Work For You — Not the Carriers
✅ Compare Multiple Top Carriers
✅ Free Personalized Review
✅ Year-Round Support
✅ Same Agent Every Time
✅ No Cost to You — Ever
CYA Insurance Agency
vs. The Other Guys
See why Guthrie families choose a local independent broker over a national call center.
National Call Center
❌ Random Rep in Another State
❌ Works for One Company
❌ Limited to One or Two Options
❌ Generic Sales Script
❌ Enrollment Season Only
❌ Different Rep Every Call
❌ May Charge Fees
Medicare Insurance in Guthrie
Turning 65 in Guthrie? You have more choices than you might think — and the wrong choice can cost you thousands. CYA Insurance Agency helps Guthrie residents compare top Medicare carriers at no cost.
✅ Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans — pairs with Original Medicare for low out-of-pocket costs.
✅ Medicare Advantage plans (Part C) — bundled coverage with provider networks.
✅ Part D Prescription Drug plans — standalone coverage for your medications.
✅ Dental, vision, hearing and supplemental benefits.
Annual Election Period runs October 15 – December 7. Every recommendation we make is based on your situation — not a sales quota. That's what independent means.
Health Insurance in Guthrie
If you're under 65 or not yet Medicare-eligible, CYA Insurance Agency can help you find the right health coverage for you and your family in Guthrie. We work with multiple top carriers to compare options that fit your doctors, your budget, and your situation.
✅ ACA Marketplace plans — individual and family coverage with potential subsidies.
✅ Short-term health insurance options for gap coverage.
✅ Small business group health plans for Guthrie employers.
✅ Supplemental coverage — dental, vision, accident, and critical illness plans.
Open Enrollment runs November 1 – December 15. Had a life change? You may qualify to enroll right now — call us to find out.
Life Insurance in Guthrie
Life insurance is one of the most important financial decisions your family can make — and one of the most misunderstood. CYA Insurance Agency helps Guthrie residents find the right life insurance coverage at the right price, without the confusing sales pitch.
✅ Term life insurance — affordable coverage for a set period of time, ideal for families and mortgage protection.
✅ Indexed Universal Life (IUL) — permanent coverage with cash value growth potential.
✅ Final expense insurance — smaller policies designed to cover end-of-life costs and relieve your family of financial burden.
✅ Key person and business life insurance for Guthrie small business owners.
Every policy we recommend is based on your family's needs — not a commission target. That's what independent means.
What Our Clients Are Saying
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
"Trent walked me through every option without any pressure. I had no idea I had so many choices for Medicare. I finally feel confident about my coverage."
— Patricia M., Oklahoma Client
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
"I was completely lost on the ACA Marketplace until CYA Insurance stepped in. They found me a plan that covered my doctors and saved me over $200 a month."
— James R., Oklahoma Client
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
"Same agent every time I call, no runaround, no sales pressure. That's hard to find. I've referred three of my neighbors already."
— Linda K., Oklahoma Client
Independent reviews from real CYA Insurance Agency clients.